I just finished reading your column about Charlie Foster's
incident with the PGC. It reminded me of an experience that
I had last year with an officer of the Fish and Boat
Commission, although the outcome in my case was not nearly
as serious as Mr. Foster's. I thought you might be
interested in hearing it - you can add it to your growing
archives of
stories about the activities of these "public servants."
I was interested in taking my three young grandchildren on a trout fishing
trip on one of Pennsylvania's streams. My objective was to
attempt to foster in them at an early age an appreciation
for fishing. They were 6, 5, and 3 years old at the time.
I decided to take them to Ole Bull State Park in Potter
County and fish the section of Kettle Creek there that was
designated for children under twelve. I purchased a license
and we wenton the second weekend of trout season in order to
avoid the opening day crowds. After staying overnight in a
local historic hotel, we had breakfast and proceeded to the
park to fish.
When we arrived at the park, there were only several kids fishing in the
designated area, including what appeared to be a mother with
her son who was about ten years old. I also noticed that
two uniformed Fish and Boat Commission officers were there,
one male and one female. I did not notice anyone having
much luck catching fish.
We got our gear out and made our way to the stream. I baited the hooks
and assisted the kids with casting, reeling, un-snagging,
and untangling their lines. With three young, rambunctious
kids attempting to learn how to fish I felt like a
one-armed paperhanger at times. In the midst of this barely
controlled chaos, I noticed that the mother and son were now
at a picnic table back away from the stream talking to the
two officers.
The male officer walked down toward me along the stream and told me in a
somewhat threatening tone that I had better be careful as to
what I was doing. I was confused and asked him for a
clarification. He stated that this area of the stream was
designated for fishing by children and that if I assisted my
grandchildren too much I would end up getting a $75 citation
just like the lady back at the picnic table was now being
assessed. I could hardly believe what he was telling me and
tried to explain that the kids were quite young, on their
first trout fishing trip, and needed assistance just to get
the line in the water. He told me that if the kids were too
young to fish without assistance, I should take them back to
the park's playground area where they could play on the
swings. I "thanked" him for the warning and assured him
that I did not want to do something that would garner me a
$75 fine. The woman who they had cited and her son got into
their vehicle and left. We too packed up our gear and
headed out without having caught any fish.
I strongly believe that it is this type of heavy-handed enforcement
tactics that discourages many people from participating in
outdoor activities such as hunting and fishing. In this
instance, that mother did an admirable
bit of parenting by taking the time to take her young
son out for a day of fishing and what does she get as a
reward - a $75 fine from the very people who are supposed to
be promoting fishing!!! I'm quite certain that those
officers have deterred both her and her son from participating in fishing
for a long time if not forever. With "ambassadors of good
will" such as this, it is no wonder that the number of
people getting or staying
involved in hunting and fishing is declining.